Mr. Wright Flooring Inc. logo
How to Choose Flooring for Your Home: A Jacksonville Guide

Laminate vs. Vinyl Plank Flooring: How They Really Differ

Laminate has a wood-based core and LVP has none. Here is how they compare on scratches, water, installation and warranties, using Mohawk's and Pergo's own terms.

Mr. Wright Flooring · Nov 18, 2026

Empty bright room with a light wood-look plank floor

The main difference between laminate and vinyl plank flooring is what they are made of. Mohawk describes laminate as made of wood, and premium laminate as having a high-density fiberboard core, while luxury vinyl plank (LVP) contains zero wood, which Mohawk says makes it far more water resistant. Laminate's edge is scratch resistance, where Mohawk's FAQ says laminate wins.

Mr. Wright Flooring is a family-owned flooring company in Jacksonville and an authorized Mohawk retailer. We sell and install laminate and luxury vinyl plank, including Mohawk's RevWood laminate and SolidTech vinyl. This comparison is part of our guide to choosing flooring, and each point below names the manufacturer it comes from.

How laminate and vinyl plank are built

Mohawk describes premium laminate in four layers: a high-density fiberboard core, a high-resolution design layer that mimics hardwood, a durable wear layer, and a backing layer on the bottom for stability. Mohawk sells its RevWood line as premium laminated wood, made in the USA, with what Mohawk calls the look of hardwood with the performance of laminate.

Vinyl plank is built around a different core. Mohawk says luxury vinyl comes in many constructions, and the most popular for homes is rigid LVT, named for its rigid core. In premium products that core is a plastic-stone composite or PVC, topped by a high-definition design layer and a protective wear layer. Pergo describes its Extreme luxury vinyl the same way, layer by layer: a wear layer, a design layer, a rigid composite core, a locking system and an attached pad.

Mohawk's FAQ also names a third group, hybrid resilient, which it describes as layered flooring that combines laminate and vinyl.

Key takeaway

In premium products, laminate starts with a high-density fiberboard core and vinyl plank with a plastic-stone composite or PVC core, and Mohawk says vinyl's lack of wood is what makes it far more water resistant.

Premium laminate's four layers, as Mohawk describes them

Core

A high-density fiberboard core.

Design layer

A high-resolution design layer that mimics hardwood.

Wear layer

A durable wear layer.

Backing layer

A backing layer on the bottom for stability.

Source: Mohawk

Which resists scratches and dents better?

On scratches, Mohawk gives laminate the edge. Its hard surface FAQ says laminate wins for scratch resistance and that premium laminate is also dent resistant, while some premium LVT is designed for enhanced scratch and dent resistance. In another article, Mohawk says the gap has narrowed: laminate still has an edge, but more durable LVT wear layers have improved vinyl's scratch resistance.

Living room with a dark plank floor

Thickness and core density matter for both. Mohawk's FAQ says thicker planks correlate with durability and feel sturdier underfoot, and denser cores help resist dents and moisture. On the vinyl side, Mohawk's SolidTech warranty defines wear-through as complete loss of the wear layer so the printed design is altered, and it does not count a loss of gloss as wear.

If you have pets, Mohawk's care guidance for its RevWood and TecWood floors is simple: keep pet nails trimmed to minimize scratches. Our guide to the best flooring for pets and kids covers the pet warranties line by line.

How laminate and vinyl handle water

This is where the two split. Mohawk says vinyl's lack of wood makes it far more water resistant. Even so, Mohawk cautions that not all LVT floors are 100% waterproof, so the warranty on the exact product decides what is covered.

On the vinyl side, Mohawk warrants its SolidTech luxury vinyl as 100% waterproof, scoped to topical water, meaning spills on top of the floor. It does not cover water from below the floor, flooding, or the subfloor and adhesives.

On the laminate side, Mohawk's RevWood warranties change by sub-line. RevWood Essentials carries a Wet Resistance Warranty, under which spills left more than 30 minutes may damage the floor and void the warranty. RevWood Select carries the tier Mohawk calls its Waterproof Warranty, and RevWood Plus and Premier carry WetProtect. Our article on waterproof vs. water-resistant flooring explains what each tier covers.

Key takeaway

Vinyl plank holds the water advantage by material, but on both floors the sub-line's warranty sets what water is covered.

Laminate vs. vinyl plank, as Mohawk describes them
LaminateLuxury vinyl plank
Core in premium productsHigh-density fiberboardRigid plastic-stone composite or PVC
Wood contentMade of woodZero wood, which Mohawk says makes it far more water resistant
Scratches and dentsMohawk's FAQ says laminate wins; premium laminate is also dent resistantSome premium LVT is designed for enhanced scratch and dent resistance
Water warranty exampleRevWood: Wet Resistance on Essentials (30-minute spill limit); WetProtect on Plus and PremierSolidTech: 100% waterproof for topical water; not water from below, flooding, subfloor or adhesives

Sources: Mohawk hard surface FAQ; Mohawk SolidTech and RevWood warranties

Looks, installation and where each can go

Both can pass for wood. Mohawk's FAQ credits three details: embossed-in-register texture that matches the grain pattern, beveled edges that mimic real wood planks, and matte finishes with less shine.

Open-plan living and dining space with a gray plank floor

Mohawk says luxury vinyl planks or tiles snap together or glue down. It also says seasoned DIYers can install some rigid vinyl and laminate products successfully, though most people leave installation to the pros.

Laminate comes with room limits. Mohawk's RevWood instructions call for climate-controlled indoor rooms at 35% to 65% relative humidity and 60°F to 85°F, and they rule out rooms with a floor drain and floors with a sump pump. RevWood can go above, on or below grade, but a moisture test of the subfloor is required. Over concrete, Mohawk calls for a polyethylene vapor barrier or a Performance Accessories MoistureBarrier with seams overlapped 8 inches or more. Pergo's FAQ likewise says its floors should not go in rooms with sump pumps or floor drains. For slab installs, see glue-down vs. floating floors over concrete.

Is Pergo laminate or vinyl?

It depends on the Pergo line, and Pergo's own pages do not all agree. Pergo's product pages list Pergo Extreme as luxury vinyl and Pergo Elements as laminate. A Pergo blog post from August 21, 2025, classifies them the other way around, calling Extreme laminate and Elements luxury vinyl. We go by the product pages, and we suggest checking the product's own installation instructions and warranty before you decide, because those documents set the rules.

Which is right for your room?

Mohawk's FAQ sums up the choice for homes with pets and kids: laminate is great for scratch resistance, and waterproof vinyl stands strongest against accidents (on Mohawk's SolidTech, that waterproof warranty covers topical water only). Mohawk also lists kitchens, bathrooms, laundry rooms, basements and rooms with pets or children as moisture-prone rooms that need water-resistant or waterproof flooring. Our guide to flooring for kitchens and bathrooms covers wet rooms in detail, and what LVP flooring is explains vinyl plank from the core up.

You can buy either floor from us and have our crew install it, have us install a floor you bought elsewhere through professional installation, or buy it from us and install it yourself or with your own crew. Every project we install is supervised by an experienced team leader who keeps the install inside the manufacturer's warranty guidelines. Request a free estimate and we will measure your home at no charge.

Frequently asked questions

Is laminate or vinyl plank better?

Neither is better everywhere. Mohawk's FAQ says laminate wins for scratch resistance, while vinyl contains zero wood, which Mohawk says makes it far more water resistant. For homes with pets and kids, Mohawk's FAQ suggests laminate for scratch resistance and waterproof vinyl for accidents; on Mohawk's SolidTech, that waterproof warranty covers topical water only, not water from below or flooding. The warranty on the exact product matters too, because Mohawk's SolidTech vinyl and its RevWood laminate sub-lines carry different water coverage.

Which is more scratch resistant, laminate or LVP?

Mohawk gives laminate the edge. Its FAQ says laminate wins for scratch resistance and premium laminate is also dent resistant. Mohawk adds that some premium LVT is designed for enhanced scratch and dent resistance, and that more durable LVT wear layers have narrowed the gap. Mohawk's care guidance for its RevWood and TecWood floors also says to keep pet nails trimmed to minimize scratches.

Which handles water better, laminate or vinyl plank?

Mohawk says vinyl contains zero wood, which makes it far more water resistant. Coverage still depends on the product. Mohawk's SolidTech vinyl is warranted as 100% waterproof against topical water, but not water from below or flooding. Mohawk's RevWood Essentials laminate carries a Wet Resistance Warranty with a 30-minute limit on standing spills, while RevWood Plus and Premier carry WetProtect.

Can laminate go in a bathroom?

Check the product's instructions first. Mohawk's RevWood laminate is meant for climate-controlled indoor rooms and should not go in a room with a floor drain or over a floor with a sump pump. Pergo's FAQ says the same about sump pumps and floor drains, and it points to product-specific instructions for wet areas such as bathrooms with showers or mudrooms, because installation methods vary by product.

Can I install laminate or vinyl plank myself?

Mohawk says seasoned DIYers can install some rigid vinyl and laminate products successfully, but most people leave installation to the pros. If you want to do it yourself, you can buy the material from us and install it yourself or hire your own crew. Follow the manufacturer's instructions closely, since Mohawk's RevWood instructions include steps such as a subfloor moisture test and a vapor barrier over concrete.

Is Pergo laminate or vinyl?

It depends on the line. Pergo's product pages list Pergo Extreme as luxury vinyl and Pergo Elements as laminate, while a Pergo blog post from August 21, 2025 classifies them the other way around. Pergo's FAQ describes Extreme with a wear layer, a design layer, a rigid composite core, a locking system and an attached pad. Check the product's own installation instructions and warranty before you buy.

Thinking about new floors?

The same crew, still family-owned. Free in-home estimate across Jacksonville and Northeast Florida.